In 2024, 58.5 percent of Google searches ended without a click – a sharp wake-up call for marketers who relied on organic search. Two years later, the trend shows no signs of reversing: a follow-up study now reveals that 68 percent of Google searches end without a click.
AI-generated answers are one of the main reasons for this change in behavior: users who are shown an AI-generated response are nearly half as likely to click through compared with those who see only a list of blue links. But the bigger shift isn’t confined to the search results page. Consumers are also increasingly turning towards social media, creator content, and other AI interfaces, like ChatGPT, to find brands and search for products, upending the familiar click-and-browse path to purchase.
As AI becomes increasingly integrated into consumer search behavior, brands must consider how their digital presence shapes perception before a consumer ever visits their website.
With customers moving across diverse media, the traditional model of measuring clicks and conversions no longer paints an accurate picture of what drives consumer decision-making. At the same time, consumer behavior is becoming more selective. Awin’s research shows shoppers increasingly seek reassurance before they buy, whether through reviews, creators, editorial content or AI assistants. We call this the Confidence Economy. Growth is no longer simply about reaching more consumers. It’s about understanding which interactions reduce uncertainty and ultimately influence purchase decisions.
But the absence of a click doesn’t mean the absence of influence. For example, a customer might first see a publisher recommend a product on Instagram, then switch to Google to read an AI-generated summary about its feature based on content that same publisher has produced, then pivot to ChatGPT for more detailed follow-up questions before finally heading to a retailer’s website. It’s this cross-platform, publisher-mediated journey – not any single AI answer box – where the real measurement gap sits, and where a new measurement model needs to focus. Many of these moments of influence are created by publishers. Editorial sites, creators, comparison platforms, and communities increasingly shape the information AI systems surface.
As AI becomes a new layer of discovery, trusted publisher content doesn’t become less valuable. It becomes one of the primary inputs into how consumers evaluate brands. And without clear attribution signals, all of these moments of influence are lost in the “dark funnel,” i.e., the new unseen spaces where customer perception is shaped, decisions are made, and marketers are left vying for a way in.
How can marketers regain visibility into this new, non-linear customer journey? They need a new measurement setup that goes beyond clicks.
Counting Clicks and Modelling AI Visibility Will Not Be Enough
Many brands still rely solely on traditional click-based measurement when assessing publisher influence on consumer interest and activity, and this is becoming increasingly inaccurate as the foundations of content discovery seismically shift towards zero-click journeys.
Many brands have responded by investing in Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) solutions — an important step, but one that generates only a single signal, and relying on one signal isn’t robust enough to pivot a multi-billion-dollar industry like affiliate marketing away from its established investment practices. The challenge isn’t simply understanding whether a brand appears in AEO-generated answers. It’s understanding how publishers, creators, communities, and AI interactions combine to influence purchase decisions. This reflects a broader shift in digital marketing toward AI-driven insights and more personalized engagement.
All AEO tools will incorporate the outputs of sample prompts and then use that data to infer real user behavior, alongside other methods. While this method can give marketers a broad idea of what customers are searching for and what kind of brands and products might surface in response, it is still simulated. That’s because the results don’t go to a real person: they’re observed after being input into the API of the model providers, with varying degrees of sophistication. Their application to real users is inferred — they show what could plausibly appear in an AI answer, not definitively what a real customer was shown.
If marketers want real insights into how customers are discovering, engaging, and ultimately choosing brands in the new AI-driven discovery landscape, it’s not enough to shift from standard click-based measurement to modelled AI visibility; they need to validate value from multiple sources.
Looking Beyond Predictions to Real Demand
Alongside AEO data, two additional signals are helping marketers to understand what makes brands more visible and how they influence consumers:
1. Visibility into traffic and engagement coming from AI platforms. By analyzing first-party data, brands can identify when users arrive from AI platforms, providing marketers with a clearer picture of how AI is influencing their customers’ journeys.
2. Understanding which content AI platforms are using to generate responses. This gives marketers new visibility into the content influencing consumers before they ever reach a website, helping to shine a light on what has traditionally been defined as ‘dark funnel’ activity.
These signals move AI visibility from assumptions toward measurable insights. Marketers are empowered with a more complete view of how AI is shaping awareness, consideration and purchasing decisions, instead of relying on traditional click-based metrics.
For marketers under pressure to demonstrate results and justify investments, this approach helps them validate their decisions, tailor campaigns, and allocate spend accordingly. Advertisers, meanwhile, can get a more accurate look at how publisher content contributes to their brand’s AI visibility. And, in turn, publishers can earn greater recognition for the role their content plays in AI-discovery and engagement.
Finding Light in the Dark Funnel
The future of marketing will be won by those that understand influence wherever it happens. AI visibility is an important part of that picture, but only one part. The bigger opportunity is connecting every meaningful signal – from trusted publisher recommendations and creator content to AI citations and first-party data – into a richer understanding of how customers discover, evaluate and choose brands.
None of this works without publishers. The trusted content that powers AI discovery creates value long before a consumer clicks, yet much of that influence remains invisible. As better measurement emerges, brands will be able to recognize and reward publishers for both traffic and the role they play in shaping discovery and purchase decisions. The real question is how quickly the industry will adapt to it.\
The author, Paul Stewart, works at Awin.